There have apparently been some rather ridiculous claims that you will be turned into a transhuman if you receive the mRNA vaccines for SARS-CoV-2 (which causes COVID-19).
For instance, on the website Stop World Control, there’s a quote that reads:
“[…] these new vaccines can alter our DNA, turning us into hybrids. The plans are to connect humans to artificial intelligence and global control networks. This is the start of transhumanism, turning us into HUMANS 2.0.
That might sound cool for those who watched too many sci-fi movies, but the reality is that it would end our autonomy and make us slaves of globalist tech companies who can then control us, without us being aware of it. “
Stop World Control – The Battle for Humanity (Dr Madej)
These vaccines will not permanently alter your DNA or genetically engineer you. They won’t alter your autonomy (except in the sense that you might be able to go outside again without fearing getting infected or worsening this pandemic). They won’t connect you to any AI.
There’s a good write-up by David Gorski over at Science-Based Medicine that explains the science (hat tip for the inspiration for this post too). You can read that here: No, the Moderna and Pfizer RNA vaccines against COVID-19 will not “permanently alter your DNA”
But there is a sense in which vaccines do make you transhuman. And I don’t mean that all vaccines alter your DNA (even though apparently some are claiming that, but they’re wrong).
No, I mean more in the serious sense that vaccines enhance your immunity to a disease, without you having to get that disease. Vaccines are a human enhancement. They don’t cure you of a malady (because you don’t have one yet). Instead they make your immune system better, adding a new capability, so you can remain healthy for longer. How does that differ from, say, enhancing your reflexes to better avoid injuries from accidents or giving an anti-ageing enhancement to prevent age-related diseases? If the military gives soldiers vaccines against potential bioweapons like anthrax, why couldn’t astronauts be given modifications to their bones to counter bone loss in space missions?
Indeed, some of the recent stories involving gene editing to confer disease resistance seem (aside from the mechanism, the altering of DNA) to be identical in effect to a vaccine (though, as I pointed out, it’s not clear this is an enhancement, given the risks).
People have made this link between human enhancement and vaccines for a while, both to justify human enhancement saying it’s no different to vaccines (eg. Quigley and Harris 2007, Roberts 2014) or to stir up anti-vaccination ideas by scaring people with the threat of transhumanism. The fact that vaccines are given to children makes it quite easy to compare vaccination to designer babies, or other situations where human enhancement is given to people without their consent.
Ultimately, I think the distinction between therapy and enhancement is pretty baseless and should not be relevant at all. We should instead look at the pros and cons of a particular change, on the individual but also to others. In the case of vaccines, it’s almost certain that the benefits to both the individual and to society are going to be very large and outweigh the risks (especially with proper pre-vaccination screening). With other forms of human enhancement, it’s not quite as obvious. It may well be the technology to make people stronger, faster or smarter will be good only for those individuals who can access that technology and be detrimental to others by comparison. If that’s the case, then that’s the basis of the argument against that technology. Such an argument could be used against a cure to a disease too, if that disease was rampant and proper medical treatments only available to a few while everyone else must suffer (the ‘fairness’ argument then would be that nobody should receive the cure, or we should try our best that everyone should receive access to it if they want it).
Whether something is enhancement or not carries no weight in the argument. We should only care about whether people are better off as a result. At least with these vaccines, we can be pretty sure it will be a benefit to humankind.